guidance

Moissanite v diamonds: Everything you need to know

Curious about moissanite? Having trouble deciding which gemstone to use for your ring? Read on to find out more about the key difference between moissanite and diamonds (both mined and lab grown!)

Moissanite v diamonds: Everything you need to know

What is Moissanite?

Moissanites are a type of mineral in the same way that a diamond (or any type of gemstone) is. Outside of it's use in jewellery it's found in many industrial processes under the more common name of silicon carbide or carborundum.

You might be surprised, but naturally occurring moissanite is one of the rarest minerals on earth, in contrast to diamonds which are one of the more common. The discovery of this mineral is truly other wordly, with it's first recorded occurrence being found in the crater of a crashed meteorite.

The French chemist Henri Moissan mistakenly thought the minerals he had discovered in 1893 were diamonds, but 9 years later realised that they were in fact an entirely new material, silicon carbide.

Around the same time, American inventor Edward G. Acheson had stumbled on a way to synthesise silicon carbide. Originally attempting to grow diamonds, his manufacturing process (more about that below) led to the discovery of small green crystals which had comparable hardness to diamonds. He began selling the material (which he named Carborundum) as a means to polish gems.

In modern times, the original patent filed by Archeson has long since expired, meaning the material is manufactured all around the world for both cosmetic and industrial purposes.

Moissanite v diamonds

Moissanites and diamonds share many similar qualities, but they are in fact two completely different materials with some small, but very noticeable differences.

Durability

Minerals are measured on a hardness scale, which is measured in Ohms. Diamonds are the hardest minerals known to man, so naturally they set the upper end of the scale with a score of 10. Moissanites are also very hard, measuring at 9.25 ohms. For a reference point, rubies have a score of 9 ohms.

Cost

Diamond prices can vary depending on the 4 Cs (Cut, Carat, Colour and Clarity). Moissanite prices are typically only influenced by the carat of the stone. They are universally cheaper than diamonds when comparing similar carat sizes.

Sourcing

Naturally occurring moissanite is one of the rarest minerals on earth, with only a handful of deposits being found throughout history. The knowledge to synthesise moissanite was uncovered over 100 years ago and as such, all moissanite sold today has synthetic origins.

Similar to lab diamonds, this means the impact of large scale mining operations both on the environment and workers is non-existent. Millions of tons of earth don't have to be moved to uncover moissanites, and they don't end up as currency in human conflict. Both of which are major issues in the diamond industry.

This means moissanites are a much more ethical choice compared to mined diamonds, but are comparable to lab grown diamonds.

Comparing the 4 Cs

All diamonds are graded using the 4 Cs. They are carat, cut, clarity and colour. These 4 qualities combined give an indication of overall quality and cost of a diamond. As moissanites are very similar to diamonds, we can apply the 4 Cs to them too and compare the major differences.

Colour

A quality diamond has no trace of colour and will always display a dazzling white appearance. Moissanite on the other hand can shine with a yellow or grey tinge in certain lights. The bigger the stone, the more noticeable this will be, meaning you will never be able to get the same colour quality in a moissanite that you get in a diamond.

Clarity

Moissanites refract light to a higher degree than diamonds, which on paper sounds like a good thing. But under certain lighting conditions, it can be a bit too much, giving an undesirable effect to some people. Diamonds shine to a different degree than moissanites. They refract, reflect and have a distinct surface sparkle which gives diamonds their unique and brilliant shine.

Cut

Diamonds and moissanites can be cut into more or less the same shapes as each other, however due to moissanites inherent chemical composition, the same cuts in different materials can react to light differently.

Carat

Diamonds and moissanites can come in the same carat weights, however the larger you go with moissanites their imperfections compared to diamonds can become more noticeable. Larger moissanites will have a more noticeable grey or yellow tint and the differences in reflections will be more pronounced.

Moissanites v lab diamonds

Many comparisons are made between moissanite and lab grown diamonds, due to their shared origins in labs, as opposed to being found naturally occurring in nature. However, this comparison is flawed in many ways.

Moissanites and diamonds are two completely different materials, with their own distinct chemical make up. Lab diamonds are structurally and chemically identical to mined diamonds, with only their origin differing.

Lab diamonds combine the superior quality of diamonds with the much lower environmental impact of moissanite. Meaning with lab diamonds you get a superior gemstone for your jewellery, with the same ethical origins as moissanite. That's why lab diamond engagement rings are our preferred choice of gemstones for all our rings.

What should you use in your ring?

The choice between moissanite and diamonds for most people comes down to price. Moissanites are a fraction of the price, but don't give you the same shine as diamonds do. For a lot of people, that's fine, but if your heart is set on a diamond then moissanites simply aren't a good alternative in our opinion as they don't have the same colour quality or shine.

A good alternative is a lab grown diamond which is absolutely identical to a mined diamond, but have much more ethical origins and a lower cost.

Further reading

Guides

Emerald engagement rings - A full buying guide

The beautiful green emerald sits alongside diamonds, sapphires and rubies in the ‘Big 4’ of gemstones. 

A favourite of the Egyptian Queen Cleopatra, emeralds have been mined since at least 300BC, leaving their mark on history whilst still being one of the most sought after gems of modern times.

Today we’re going to help you get familiar with these luscious gemstones as well as giving you some practical tips if you’re looking to use them in your engagement ring.

Read More

How to buy ethical diamonds

At Nightingale we’re all about ethical diamonds. And as far as we’re concerned, they should be the minimum standard when making jewellery. 

Unfortunately, that’s not the case. It took a lot of time and effort for us to find sustainable diamond suppliers for our ethical engagement rings and we'd rather you didn’t have to go through the same trouble.

So we’re going to lay out all the knowledge we have to help you find a truly ethical diamond.

Read More

The Valentine's Day engagement ring guide

One of our favourite times of year is nearly upon us. Valentine’s Day!

Being the most popular engagement date of the year, we naturally get a lot of questions from customers. So we thought why not put everything we know into a handy engagement ring guide for Valentine’s Day 2022!

Here’s what we’ll cover...

  • Popular engagement ring styles for 2022
  • Tips for finding the perfect ring
  • Advice on making the most of your budget

Read More

The complete Toi et Moi engagement ring guide

A firm contender for the most romantic style of engagement ring, the symbolism of the Toi et Moi ring (or Moi et Toi as they're also known) is plain for all to see. Two gemstones. One representing you. One representing your soulmate.

This beautiful design style is enjoying a revival which looks to continue well into 2022 and beyond. If you're interested in a toi et moi engagement ring you'll find all the information you need to know right here in our easy guide.

Read More

White gold v Platinum - Which is best for engagement rings?

White gold and platinum can give a similar aesthetic to your engagement ring, but there are some important differences between the two metals which can be important when choosing between them.

Both are very popular choices for engagement rings, so we thought it best to give you a simple guide to help you decide.

Read More

How to get the perfect engagement ring for any budget

Deciding to propose to your partner is a big decision. And along with that decision usually comes a big financial commitment to buy a suitable engagement ring. 

Here's 6 tips to help you get a ring that's perfect for you and your budget.

Read More

Choosing the right metal for your bespoke ring

Choosing the right metal for your bespoke engagement ring is one of the most important choices you can make when creating a ring. The right material sets the overall style of your ring and if done correctly, complements your choice of gemstone and mount.

Read More

Buying ethical diamond jewellery in 2021

Looking to make your next jewellery purchase more ethical? That's great to hear! But being completely honest, buying ethically is not as easy as it should be in 2021.

Read More

Pearl buying guide

Prized and admired for millennia. As the first true gems ever to be used as adornments, the history of pearls in jewellery is nearly as old as the history of civilisation itself.

Read More

Diamond grading certificates explained

A diamond certificate is the evaluation by a third party accredited gemological laboratory of your diamond. In addition to the diamonds carat weight and measurements, a certificate includes grades for the diamonds cut colour and clarity.

Read More

Ring sizing guide

The last thing we at Nightingale want is to supply a ring and at the crucial ‘down on one knee’ moment it turns out to be too large or too small. Nightingale offer one adjustment free in the first three months.

Read More

Hallmarks

It is mandatory in Great Britain for precious metals that meet the weight criteria to be assayed and hallmarked (stamped) to indicate the type and fineness of the metal.

Read More

Diamond buying guide

There are many beautiful gemstones that have been created by nature and mined from the earth but the most regal of them all is the diamond. The mysterious diamond is the most popular gemstone of them all and the one that has the most myths and legends associated with it.

Read More

Lab grown diamonds: Everything you need to know

Wondering what exactly a lab grown diamond is and why they're a perfect ethical alternative to mined diamonds? Find out here...

Read More

Coloured diamonds

Nightingale can supply an outstanding collection of coloured diamonds loose or set within a bespoke or finished piece of Nightingale jewellery.

Read More